Ten of the Most Unusual Pizza Toppings in NJ

We take our pizza seriously here in New Jersey.

Many old-school pizza aficionados turn their noses up at some of the outrageous toppings used on pizza.

And with good reason.  For instance, putting pineapple on a pizza is an abomination, and should never be allowed.

Sometimes, when you see what people are putting on their pizzas, you have to ask, when does a pizza stop being a pizza?

I've created a list of some of the more unusual pizzas available in New Jersey.

I'll leave it up to you to judge the merits of these pizzas.

Adrian's   200 Hackensack St Wood-Ridge

They have something they call, Breakfast Anytime Pizza that may as well be called a heart attack on dough.

Half Taylor Ham (or Pork Roll, whatever), half bacon, Jack and Cheddar cheese, and sunny-side-up eggs.

Papa's Tomato Pies  19 Robbinsville-Allentown Rd, Robbinsville

Back in the day, the Trenton area was well-known for their Tomato pies. They were  Pizzas without the cheese.  They were delicious.

These days, people are talking about a creation called Mustard Pies.

These pies have spicy brown mustard between the crust and cheese and it's topped with tomato, and any other topping you desire.

The result is a unique taste that's very good.

Carluccio's Coal Fired Pizza  1200 New Road, Northfield

Honey Glazed Chicken Cutlet Cooked in Homemade Honey Bualo Sauce, Topped with Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions & Blue Cheese Dressing.

The coal-fired oven makes a difference.  Come with an appetite.  Their pizza is very filling.

Get our free mobile app

Tony Boloney's 300 Oriental Ave, (as well as locations in Hoboken, Margate, and Jersey City)

Everything about this place and their pizza is unusual, but that's the charm.

Try the Jewish Cowboy, 8 hour burnt end brisket, Passover sauce, dry aged mozzarella, babushka beet horseradish, havarti.  Oy!

The Brothers Restaurant  188 West Front Street, Red Bank

Have you ever had a hard time choosing between a hot dog or pizza for dinner?

You won't have that problem here.

Try their Italian Hotdog Pizza.  It comes with Peppers, Onions, Potatoes & Hotdog

Julio's Pizza Company  297 Main Street, Keansburg

Home of Joe Joe's Pickle Pie.  Yes, PICKLES.

Housemade garlic parm sauce, mozzarella, and pickle chips.