If you've noticed more stuff locked behind plexiglass at your local CVS or Target lately, you're not imagining things. Shoplifting has been a hot topic in New Jersey for the last couple of years, with retailers complaining about rising theft and lawmakers pushing tougher penalties for organized retail crime rings.

But where in the Garden State is it actually happening the most?

We went straight to the source. Using the FBI's Crime Data Explorer, we pulled every shoplifting offense reported by New Jersey police departments in 2025, the most recent full year available. Statewide, local departments reported 29,363 shoplifting offenses last year.

YOU'LL ALSO LIKE:

NJ Target Shoppers May Be Surprised That These Are The 15 Most Stolen Items

Popular Clothing Retailer Closing All NJ Locations

Where Are The Most Store Thefts in New Jersey?

The results might surprise you. You'd probably guess the state's biggest cities would dominate the list, but that's not really how it works. Shoplifting follows the stores, not the population. Towns with big malls, outlet centers, and busy highway shopping corridors tend to rack up the highest numbers, even if they don't have many residents. That's how a borough of about 27,000 people like Paramus ends up near the top, while Newark, the state's biggest city, doesn't even crack the top 25.

It's also worth remembering what these numbers are and aren't. A high count doesn't mean a town is unsafe to live in. In many cases, it means the town is a regional shopping destination with a busy, proactive police department that responds to and logs retail theft calls. Plenty of shoplifting never gets reported, since stores don't always call the police.

Below, we're counting down the 25 New Jersey towns that reported the most shoplifting offenses in 2025. For each one, we've included the 2025 total, how it compared to 2024 (where data was available), and the rate per 1,000 residents so you can see how it stacks up for the town's size.

These 25 NJ Towns Reported the Most Shoplifting

Shoplifting follows stores, not populations. Using the FBI’s latest crime data, we ranked the 25 New Jersey towns that reported the most shoplifting offenses last year.

Gallery Credit: Matt Ryan

Lock Your Doors: The 25 New Jersey Towns Where Burglaries Hit Hardest

We crunched the latest FBI burglary numbers for more than 130 New Jersey towns.

Gallery Credit: Matt Ryan

More From Lite 96.9 WFPG